I have to say, after I watched the heartwarming and terrific film In America, I was deeply moved by the loving family. For a long time, I can’t get out of their struggling story. Without any glaring special effects, just through a ten-year-old girl Christine’s narration, In America beats all the American blockbuster, in my eyes.
At the beginning of the film, the shakily photographed opening scenes gives me a deep impression, which deliberately symbolizes the uncertainty of the future. Through the camcorder, the oldest daughter Christine sees the huge and brightly colored Big Apple. No one knows what’s waiting for the family, even for us… Around by the wows of the two kids in the car, let’s forget all the pains we had, facing the brand-new world.
To escape from the sad memories of their little son Frankie’s death, the young couple with two adorable daughters move into the U.S illegally, with dreams of a better life for their family. They are so poor that have to live in the slum of Manhattan, which is populated by junkies, drag queens, and assorted low-lifes. The new house is just passable, but the family are excited, with their aborative decoration, the house is filled with warmth. This is the point that touched me a lot, no matter how bad the real condition is, they never lose the heart. So, to some extent, In America is actually an inspiring film.
However, the loss of Frankie haunts every single one of the family. There are three plots I remember clearly until now. The first one is that when the immigration officer asks how many children they have, the dad still answers 3, in fact his son has been dead. And the second: after the mum gives birth to a new baby, she cries to the dad, looking for her lost son. The last one: before Christine gives a blood transfusion to the baby in danger, she announces seriously to her father, “Don’t ‘little girl’ me, I've been carrying this family on my back for more than a year.” Through the plots above, we can see the guilt and blame plague the couple all the time, and even their young daughters bear the family’s pain and try to heal their parents. Christine has been talking to Frankie every night, recalling the happy time when the family are in together. This is a children’s world that is often ignored by the adults. The director Jim Sheridan notices it, that’s commendable.
Besides the love between the family, In America gives us a glimpse of the true friendship. On their first Halloween in the states, the two girls dare to knock on the door of “the screaming man”,a black named Motell, in their building and played “trick or treat” with him, softening the dying man’s heart. Gradually, they develop a
sincere relationship. The family pull him out of his depression at the end of his life, show him their love, and make him have the last happy time. Unexpectedly, the kids’ opening arms, the whole family’s kindness finally pay off—Motell pay their debts to hospital as the last gift. We ache for him when his end comes. God bless him.
Undoubtedly, In America is a tear jerker in terms of its theme, about memory, secrets, love, loss, wishes, dreams, families growing stronger, starting over, and America as the land of opportunity, etc. Also it is elevated by strong performances by everyone involved. Paddy Considine plays Johnny, excellently showing a father who is devoted, protective, compassionate, a little crazy and weighed down by grief. And, needless to say, Samantha Morton, the famous actress, gives a stunning performance driven by the despair in her eyes. She captured every emotion a grieving mother goes through, and her nervous breakdown in the hospital is so emotionally gripping. But the most surprise is the real-world sisters, the genuine article of child actors, Sarah and Emma Bolger. They seem completely transparent, not just simple ‘cute kids’, but leave the impression they are not acting at all. When Christine sings “Desperado” at a school talent show, I nearly weep. It haunts me all the week, tugging my heartstrings.
And finally I want to add something else in the part of the text structure and the art of narratology. There are Christine’s three wishes and the image of ET throughout the whole film. The three wishes Christine prays to Frankie form the main frame of the film. And the image of ET emerges in the film several times, at a street fair, the dad wins an ET doll for the kids; a black man who calls himself an ET befriends the sisters; and the ET passes the moon like Santa Claus at the end of the film. In my opinion, maybe the ET represents the miracles, if you believe in hope and love, your dream will come true someday.
All in all, In America gives me so many levels of human emotion, purifying my soul. If only one word to describe it, that is, bravo!
http://ceh-870925.blog.163.com/blog/static/340173672008102322820365/ 一个别人家的故事.遥远但是真实.我的屏幕虽然暗了下来,但是他们的生活应该仍然在地球的另一端继续.不记得怎样开始,也不会有结束.
<新美国梦>里面有太多温情,幸与不幸都恰倒好处,巧合和奇迹也都适可而止.就好象我们的生活,公平的谁也别想占到什么便宜.就是这样的分寸,让我愿意相信它的真实.
这是一种不同于以往的感动.似乎没有什么煽情的场景对白.没有大起大落的情节,没有大喜大悲的心境.只是电影一开始,看见克里斯蒂没有笑容的美丽的脸,就觉得莫名的忧伤和担心.磕磕绊绊的生活中似乎还隐藏了巨大的不幸没有现身:( 然而意外的是,他们最终也并未遭受什么巨大的不幸,只是生活保持着不怎么顺利的状态.也许正是因为这样吧,没有特意地要感动谁,反而深深地打动了人心.孩子天使一样的笑脸和声音让我忍不住为她们祈祷,上帝不要对她们太残忍.
难忘几个片段: 克里斯蒂在台上轻轻唱着的歌."" 好温暖的声音,唱得出的希望:)
父亲投球换E.T娃娃的那一段.从一开始兴高采烈的想要试试,到最后掏出所有积蓄作为赌注.我相信我可以想象和理解,人在长久受压抑后暂时想忘记理智的冲动.
小艾瑞尔的柠檬糖:) 我想那是换做是谁都愿意相信的魔法!
快结束时在阳台和法兰奇说再见的那段.爸爸的表情变化令我感触颇深.他终于可以面对和遗忘了:) 是啊,心是空间有限的容器,装满了伤心的往事,期盼的幸福要放哪里呢?!
总的来说,是个基调不怎么快乐的电影吧.看的时候是小心翼翼的.甚至没有机会松一口气.但是片尾曲响起字幕出现的时候,心里觉得很安静,也很放心.不需要眼泪,不需要太多思考.没有觉得夸张到好笑,没有明显的情节漏洞让我失望.亦没留下遗憾和悬念~~~这是最让我满足的一种观影感受.
电影的表现手法很隐忍,又很坚持,无声的挣扎,“脆弱”的大人和“坚强”的小孩,感人的诉说。我不知道Frankie Sheriden是不是导演的儿子,但可以感觉到他通过电影温柔的看着Frankie:)
After a long journey, finally the Sullivan family enters the United States. The director chooses to start the story at this moment. The moment for the family may be a chance to restart to some degree. And also to us spectators, it can be an easy resource to look into the protagonists’ life.
Johnny and Sarah, with their daughters Christy and Ariel, have settled in a tenement in Manhattan which is occupied by drug addicts and transvestites. However, they are still filled with joy. Sarah finds a job in a restaurant as a waitress to support the family while Johnny can go on taking part in screen test to try to get a role. Nevertheless, Johnny can never find the emotions that the stage director has expected. So he has faced a lot of failures.
With the story promoting, we are told that there is a heavy stone hanging over the family. It’s the accidental death of the young son Frankie. Everybody in the family feels sorrow and guilty. Though they seldom mention it, they haven’t forgotten it for even one minute. That’s the reason why Johnny can’t feel true feelings----he had lost them all at his son’s death. And the movie here brings out an other important protagonist---the Nigerian artist and photographer Mateo. His early actions make us think he is a ferocious guy. But the turning point comes at the Halloween Day. Christy and Ariel knock Mateo’s door for the tradition “thick or treat”. Mateo has treated the girls friendly. This makes the family gradually accept this black friend, even knowing he is dying of AIDS.
Sarah is pregnant again at the risk of losing her life. Mateo falls down stairs and his life is in an emergency situation. Finally, on the one hand a baby is born prematurely and in poor health. On the other hand, Mateo pays off the family’s hospital bill before he passes away. And at last, with the birth of the new baby and the death of Mateo, Johnny finally gets over with the Frankie thing and recovers the ability of feeling things.
Life goes on.
Despite of the various complicated emotions, at my point of view, love is the key word in defining the theme of this movie. Because of loving Frankie, the family has been in deep desperate. Because of loving his wife and daughters, Johnny tried to thrown the ball to the hall over and over again. Because of loving the family, Mateo has learnt how to open his heart and treat others kindly. Love exists everywhere, connecting the Sullivan family, the white and the black, the death and the alive. Love, like warm sunshine, has filled the crevices of people’s hearts.
Just as the <Bible > says:” Love is patient; love is kind; love is not envious or boastful or arrogant or rude. It does not insist on its own way; it is not irritable or resentful; it does not rejoice in wrongdoing, but rejoices in the truth. It bears all things, hopes all things, and endures all things. Love never ends”.
Among the conspicuous protagonists, I prefer Christy most. Most people may love Ariel more for she is actually a cute and active girl. Compared with her, Christy seems to be inner going, silent and mature. With less unconscious words and less impulsive actions, Christy has adopted the camcorder to hide herself behind the lens. However, she is only a child. She believes she has been granted three wishes by her dead brother. She used to talk to Frankie at night until she realized she was talking to herself. She gave Mateo the CPR at once not considering his AIDS. She is used to keeping her feeling in her heart in order to comfort her parents. People are easily interested in Ariel. On the contrary, Christy’s sensibility demand is often ignored. This is an important factor that has influenced her character. All in all, she is a little girl who is kind-hearted, sensible and lonely. She is like the moon, not dazzling as the sun, still bringing the surrounding light quietly.
As her singing in the movie:
” Desperado, why don't you come to your senses?
Come down from your fences, open the gate
It may be raining', but there's a rainbow above you
You better let somebody love you, before it's too late”
That’s also what I have found from the movie. Love is a boat, driving our migratory hearts landing home.
主题是亲情,美国梦只是个背景而已。小女儿太可爱了!大女儿长大果然走演技派路线。Samantha Morton当时才二十出头吧,就能把这个母亲演得细致入微。导演真的有个得脑瘤死的弟弟Frankie。
08.07.16.12点04分.留意到电影结尾dedicate to Frankie,原来是导演的死去的兄弟.生活远远比想象中艰辛.号外~Ewan McGregor and Kate Winslet were originally approach to play Johnny and Sarah at the film's early stages of production when it was entitled "East of Harlem"!!!!!
温馨略带伤感
美国梦啊~~ 也不容易,但坚持下来了,日子会好过的。btw,我挺稀饭演父亲的演员,却忘记是从哪一部短萌上他的了。
美国梦 也许当我去了美国之后会知道那里并没有我所想象的那么美 可是这会使我变的更坚强 勇敢
好多事我都理解不了,比如贫穷还依旧生子,生孩子也是美国梦中的一个么,费解
非常温情的一部反映新移民在美国的奋斗与挣扎的好片。
谢里丹还真能玩煽情。。前面部分不错 然后就开始流俗了点 尾声倒也还可以 在同类题材中还是不敌《幸福来敲门》
因爱之名……
有梦就有天堂,前路荆棘,坚强面对。影片节奏把握的恰到好处,千篇一律的美国梦主题在导演的镜头下散发出新的光辉,主角表演的都很出色。看完本片很希望自己以后也能有两个女儿~
高一口語課上亞裔外教給我們看的片子,我是為了裡面的desprado開始聽eagles的麼?
一部治愈丧子之痛的电影,虽然一对爱尔兰父母深陷痛苦,但是整部影片充满了阳光和希望,他们在纽约找到了新的生活。煽情而又紧抓人心而不令人生厌。
内容有点松散,主要还是表现生活困难但还有希望吧
当爸爸投ET玩偶时 我的心紧张得缩成一团。当她们对着月亮挥着手说 bye Mateo, look after frankie 我的心又一次纠成一团。有时候生活很艰难 现状困苦 回忆折磨 仿佛已经无法进行下去。希望生活都像电影一样 历经种种后 会有好的结局。
生活艰辛,感谢有家人不离不弃的陪伴,感谢有好心人马提奥的帮助,两个小女孩好可爱。
我还是最喜欢看这种温情的家庭电影,本片可以说是很合我的胃口了。而且本片的剧本是真的写的非常好,大女儿的自白台词本身和其切入的时间都非常的巧妙和精确,结局也拍得特别好,非常加分。要说本片有什么不足的我感觉是叙事方式有点太稀碎了,很多地方都处理得太急了。本片的群戏也非常好,两个小女孩的表演是最让我印象深刻的,大女儿扮演者的表现十分出彩,小儿女就像天使一样,这两个角色也是本片的一大亮点。萨曼莎莫顿的表现也非常不错,但是戏份真的有点太少了,感觉能入围奥斯卡女主还挺爆冷的。杰曼翰苏的表现也不错,但也是出彩的片段并不是特别多且戏份有点少
有些松散,大女儿真是又乖又懂事
7/10。真的好无聊。。。剧情人为化痕迹有点重,不过我感谢导演没有煽情过度,投球赌玩偶、躲迷藏、做爱交替黑人发疯的蒙太奇、坐在月亮下劝父亲遗忘失子之痛等几段拍得挺有感染力。生命因希望而美丽,只要活着就有了奇迹。喜欢开头星条旗朦胧的镜头语言,揭示了美国梦从触不可及到逐渐清晰这一主题。
太老套,公寓地址295 East 8th Street, New York
本片获第76届奥斯卡最佳女主角、男配角和原创剧本提名。又是一部美国梦影片,所不同的是,为什么要离开加拿大来到美国?影片没有做什么交代。没有对比,真难以让人想像出这就是你要的天堂吗?最让人不可接受的就是那个拿上全家房租去赌一个超级难看的做工粗糙的E.T.玩偶。这不是脑袋有病嘛?!